As fall approaches, we begin to say goodbye to scorching days and nights and prepare to say hello to the colder ones. As that transition gets underway, we become more concerned with heating and begin to evaluate our options for the cool months ahead. There’s always the option of more expensive home heating via gas, but what about a good old fire? Any home can be equipped with a stove. But which type should you choose? Here the decision comes down to wood vs. pellet stoves, and each has its own ups and downs. Let’s take a look.
|Cost of Fuel
*Checkmark Indicates Advantage
You want a new stove, so the first consideration will likely be price. There’s a lot to love about wood and pellet stoves, but the price tag will undoubtedly stand out.
Wood Stove Pricing
Price: $3,000 – $5,000, installation included
Wood stoves average around $3,000 – $4,200 when you factor in the cost of bringing in a pro installer. For a premium model with all the bells and whistles, you may be looking at about $5,000. If your home has a chimney and a preexisting fireplace unit, installation may be simplified and you may be able to save money and opt for a fireplace insert, which sits directly inside the fireplace’s firebox. If not, you’re looking at lofty fees to fashion a ventilation system.
Pellet Stove Pricing
Price: $3,500 to $4,000, installation included
On the other hand, pellet stoves come in anywhere from $1,700 – $3,000 prior to installation fees, and could total $3,500 – $4,000 when all is said and done. That’s already lower than the higher price points of wood stoves, plus pellet stoves are able to be ventilated through a small hole in the wall, making them able to be installed anywhere in the room and saving on chimney costs.
Winner: With cost and installation flexibility, the better bet has to be a pellet stove.
The primary difference between pellet and wood stoves is their fuel source.
Wood Stove Opporating Cost
Fuel Source: Wood, ~6.5 tons per season
Cost: ~$190 per ton, ~$1,235 per season
Wood stoves operate much like fireplaces in that they burn logs. This is generally convenient and cost-effective, as firewood can at times be harvested and seasoned on your own property (free wood!) or bought by the cord from stores for low sums.
Pellet Stove Operating Cost
Fuel Source: Pellets, ~7.5 tons per season
Cost: ~$190 per ton, ~$1,425 per season
Pellet stoves utilize wood pellets for fuel, composed of sawdust or small wood chips. These chips are added to a reservoir to be burned. Pellets are harder to come by as they are specially manufactured (not available in your own backyard) and not everyone sells them. This fuel must be purchased from other areas in the US, making them somewhat less common, though plenty of regions carry them. Using pellets means planning to buy and ship the item to use. Pellets are slightly higher in price per year, though they burn longer than wood.
In either case, according to the Department of Energy, you should expect to pay about $190 for a cord of wood or ton of pellets (at 6.5 cords or 7.5 tons of pellets per season, factoring in that a ton equals 1.5 cords).
Winner: Given both the abundance of and cost per season for natural wood, wood is a winner over pellets, as it’s both affordable and accessible.
Powering Your Stove
A motorized hopper on a pellet stove.
Another aspect that distinguishes wood and pellet stoves is power.
Wood Stove Power
Power Needed: None
Wood stoves work essentially like fireplaces—add wood, light it, stoke as needed, etc. They operate completely free of power such as electricity, making them usable anytime as long as timber is available.
Pellet Stove Power
Power Needed: 100 kilowatt-hours per month, ~$9 per month
Pellet stoves rely on power no matter what. Electricity is a cornerstone in their operation, so when the power goes out, so does your fire. The electricity powers a motorized hopper that feeds the pellets into the stove. It is possible, however, to run your stove on a Uninterruptible Power Supply (UPS) backup battery or generator during power outages.
Winner: Wood. Got dry wood and a match? You’ll have fire. Pellet stoves require extra resources and expenses. With the electricity used for such a unit, you may be left in the cold during a power outage, all the while paying for 100 kilowatt-hours each month (about $9).
Pellet and wood stoves vary in their degrees of “greenness.”
Wood Stove Production
Smoke Production: 2 to 7.5 grams per hour
CO2 Production: 0.0612 pounds per kilowatt-hour
EPA-certified wood-burning stoves are tightly regulated, releasing between 2 – 7.5 grams of smoke into the air every hour— an improvement over those of the olden days that emitted 40+ grams. According to the Biomass Energy Centre in the UK, when burned, wood releases 0.00612 pounds per kilowatt-hour of CO2.
Pellet Stove Production
Smoke Production: <1 gram per hour
CO2 Production: 0.035 pounds per kilowatt-hour
Pellet stoves, however, emit almost no smoke—less than 1 gram per hour. With such a small footprint left behind, the EPA doesn’t monitor them. Additionally, as pellets are essentially wood waste, using them is a form of recycling, keeping wood particles out of landfills. According to the Biomass Energy Centre in the UK, when burned, pellets release 0.035 pounds of CO2 per kilowatt-hour.
Winner: Pellets stoves. While both wood and pellet stoves have come a long way toward cleaner operation, pellet stoves have minimal smoke and CO2 impacts and also promote recycling. Both fuels are “carbon-neutral” and are not considerable hazards.
A fire burns hot in this wood stove.
“Playing with fire” is risky business all around and one must take necessary safety precautions when tending to a fire. Everything from using appropriate kindling to wearing gloves may be essential. Beyond this, however, are the safety factors of the stoves themselves.
Wood Stove Safety
Wood stoves give off flame sparks, which may lead to burns, and these units could accumulate creosote deposits resulting in dangerous house fires down the road. Additionally, firewood has the potential to bring mold or pests into the home from outside.
Pellet Stove Safety
Pellet stoves burn cleaner and safer, without the risk of harming you or your home. The contained flames keep your family safe from flying embers and sparks, however the pellet stove will become hot to the touch. All members of your household should be made aware that the stove will become very hot, and efforts should be made to keep pets away from the device.
Winner: Wood Stoves. In terms of immediate safety, wood stoves get a big thumbs-down here, leaving pellet stoves to take center stage. Sparks, creosote buildup and house fires from wood stoves are great risks associated with wood stoves. Pellet stoves contain flames and prevent users from getting unexpected burns from flying burning debris.
An efficient pellet stove.
Your stove is there to keep you warm, so which type does that better? This all depends on the units of heat measure, or BTUs and how effectively they’re used between the fuel sources and getting heat to your space. Each stove uses great amounts of BTUs to burn logs or pellets throughout the season. However, not all of this energy is converted into usable heat.
Wood Stove Production
Firewood is used by the cord (stacked wood equaling 4 feet high x 8 feet long x 4 feet deep). According to the Department of Agriculture, every cord utilizes 15.3 million BTUs. In heating your home, you benefit from 10.7 million BTUs out of that total, enjoying a stove efficiency level of 70%.
Pellet Stove Production
On the other hand, pellets come in 40-lb bags and the stoves have a BTU output of 13.6 million per ton of pellets. From this, you soak up 11.3 million BTUs of heat. The result is greatly improved efficiency over wood stoves, coming in at about 83%.
Winner: Pellet stoves.
A chimney sweep.
Some maintenance is required no matter what type of stove you opt for. Cleanings, component checks and more all must factor in.
Wood Stove Maintenance
Wood stoves are maintained like chimneys, requiring that a certified chimney sweep be brought in annually to do an inspection of the system, including the flue and other components, and need to have residue and soot cleaned out periodically. A major maintenance consideration for wood stoves is inspecting the catalytic combustor, and that must be done 3 times per season alone.
Pellet Stove Maintenance
Pellet stoves, however, are simple to maintain, so long as you follow manufacturer recommendations. It may be as simple as checking the working order of motors and fans or removing excess debris. Maintaining a pellet stove is a straightforward and potentially less-costly process. You can do much of the checks yourself by following guidelines and don’t need to pay for as many inspections. However, if your pellet stove needs serviced, finding repairmen with the necessary skills can be difficult and repairing one of the three motors or electronic circuit board can become costly.
Winner: Pellet stoves win here, too.
A log burning in a wood stove.
Ok, admit it. After all of this talk about wood and pellet stoves, you’re wondering, which is prettier? Well, each option comes in a variety of shapes and models designed to fit well with your home décor, many fit into preexisting fireplaces and still others are freestanding models that may be moved if necessary. Both wood-burning and pellet stoves are made to be attractive whilst being functional. Therefore, the deciding factor here has to be the burn itself.
Wood Stove Aesthetics
When you look into a wood burning unit, you see orange flames licking at dried, aged logs. Still more, you take in the smoky aroma of the burning timber.
Pellet Stove Aesthetics
Pellet stoves have the same bright flames, however, that “wow” factor may be diminished for some, as the logs you’d expect to see are replaced by minuscule fragments.
Winner. Aesthetically-speaking, then, wood’s got it won. In the war of wood vs. pellet stoves, you may still wonder which stove is the better option. Strictly speaking, pellet stoves may be a better investment due to such factors as maintenance, efficiency, safety and more. But ultimately, the decision lies with you. What things are most important? If it’s the crackle of logs burning, wood may be good too! YOU decide!
In the war of wood vs. pellet stoves, you may still wonder which stove is the better option. Strictly speaking, pellet stoves may be a better investment due to such factors as maintenance, efficiency, safety and more. But ultimately, the decision lies with you. What things are most important? If it’s the crackle of logs burning, wood may be good too! YOU decide!